A Case-Based Analysis of Enforcement Orders, and the Role of Independent Compliance Audit
1.Introduction
Whenever the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) penalises a Non-Banking Financial Company (NBFC), the news usually reports only the headline number, such as “a fine of a few lakh rupees” or “new lending stopped”. What matters more to a Company Secretary or a governance professional is the paragraph in the order that explains how the regulator found the gap. That paragraph raises a simple question: would the company’s own audit programme or internal checks have found this gap first? If not, it is a warning for the company and for its auditors.
That question has become sharper since RBI rebuilt its supervision around the Scale Based Regulation (SBR) Framework, 2023 (as amended in November 2025), and gave its Enforcement Department (EFD) a cleaner separation from day-to-day supervision. The Enforcement Department acts under Section 58G read with Section 58B of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934, and, where credit bureau data is involved, under the Credit Information Companies (Regulation) Act, 2005. The law has not changed. What has changed is the way gaps are detected: RBI now reads the data, not only the files.
What is happening now. This question is very current. In a single month in 2026, RBI issued penalty orders against six NBFCs within ten days, mainly for lapses related to: customer risk reviews not done on time, accounts not classified as non-performing assets (NPAs), exposure limits crossed, and directors holding too many board positions. Again in 2026, five more NBFCs were penalised in a single week. None of the basic lapses needs advanced technology to find; each needs only a regular, independent check.
2.How RBI Finds These Gaps
RBI mainly uses the three methods below to find these gaps:
First, through offsite supervision – RBI’s Centralised Information Management System (CIMS) collects the regulatory returns filed by NBFCs and analyses them automatically. It identifies unusual lending rates (Weighted Average Lending Rate), missing disclosures, and high exposure to specific borrowers or sectors. As a result, RBI may identify possible problems even before an inspection begins.
Second, through onsite inspection – During the annual inspection, RBI officers review board minutes, Know Your Customer (KYC) records, information technology (IT) logs, customer files and other documents. The inspection checks whether the NBFC has followed the regulatory requirements.
Third, through a Control Gap Assessment – This is a focused and quicker review of one specific risk area. RBI starts it whenever offsite data points to a possible concern, whatever the annual inspection schedule says.
3.Four Years of Enforcement Data
RBI’s Annual Reports publish enforcement data by type of Regulated Entity. NBFCs face a larger share of the most serious actions, such as restrictions on business operations. These restrictions are often harsher than monetary penalties, but they are not included in the penalty amounts shown in the table below.
| Financial Year | Number of Actions Taken on NBFCs | NBFC Penalty (crore) |
| 2022-23 | 11 | 4.39 |
| 2023-24 | 22 | 11.53 |
| 2024-25 | 37* | 7.29* |
| 2025-26 | 25 | 1.76 |
*The figure for 2024-25 (37 actions and INR 7.29 crore) is reported jointly for NBFCs and Asset Reconstruction Companies.
RBI’s Annual Report for 2025-26 also shows how enforcement works in practice. Across all regulated entities (banks, co-operative banks and NBFCs), RBI issued 342 show-cause notices containing 698 charges. Only 382 charges led to monetary penalties. No enforcement action was taken on the remaining 316 charges, after the entities had replied to the notices and, where needed, been heard in person.
This shows that good compliance records and proper documentation make a real difference. An NBFC that keeps its records in order from the beginning is in a much stronger position to answer a regulatory notice. This is why strong governance in NBFCs is important.
It also shows that RBI looks more closely at larger NBFCs. Upper Layer and Middle Layer NBFCs should expect closer scrutiny. Accordingly, an NBFC’s audit should be based on its size and risk, and the same checklist should not be used for every company, every time.
4.The Four Enforcement Orders
Case 1
In a recent enforcement action, RBI directed an NBFC to stop sanctioning and disbursing gold loans, and to stop assigning, securitising or selling its gold loans, with immediate effect. The action followed an inspection based on the company’s position at the time. RBI found serious problems, including wrong assessment of the purity and weight of the pledged gold, loans above the permitted loan-to-value (LTV) limit, cash loan disbursals and collections far above the legal limit, failure to follow the standard auction process, and lack of transparency in the charges levied on customers.
Gold loans were a major part of the company’s business, at about one-third of its total loans. Since the concerns were serious, RBI imposed business restrictions instead of only a monetary penalty. A special audit followed, and the restrictions remained for several months, during which the company’s gold loan portfolio reduced significantly. Later, an inspection based on the company’s position at that time found that surplus money from gold auctions had not been returned to some borrowers, and RBI imposed a further penalty.
What should have been in place?
- Automatic monitoring of LTV limits at every branch.
- Approval controls for cash disbursals above INR 20,000.
- A clear process for gold auctions, including timely return of surplus money to borrowers.
- Regular independent checks of gold valuation.
- Sample checks of loan files to confirm compliance with LTV limits.
- Matching of auction records with the refunds actually paid to borrowers, using bank transfer details.
- Checks that loans were paid through banking channels and not in cash beyond the permitted limit.
Case 2
In another enforcement action, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) imposed a monetary penalty on an NBFC for non-compliance with certain requirements of the KYC Directions. The company had not verified customers’ Permanent Account Numbers (PAN) through the official verification facility of the Income Tax Department, and it had given more than one Unique Customer Identification Code (UCIC) to the same customer.
These may look like small lapses, but RBI treats them seriously. Simply collecting a copy of the PAN card is not enough; it must be verified. Similarly, when one customer has several UCICs, it becomes difficult to see all of that customer’s transactions together and to detect money laundering risks.
RBI has also penalised NBFCs for lapses in gold loan operations, including failure to refund surplus amounts realised from gold auctions to borrowers. Similarly, KYC non-compliance has continued to attract regulatory penalties, with several NBFCs facing enforcement action during 2026.
What should have been in place?
- PAN verification through the official portal before opening an account.
- A system to prevent duplicate UCICs for the same customer.
Case 3
In recent years, RBI has also imposed penalties on NBFCs for non-compliance with the Master Direction on Information Technology Framework for the NBFC Sector and with cyber security directions. The penalty followed a Control Gap Assessment, conducted by RBI, which focused on the company’s IT and information security controls.
RBI found three main issues:
- The company did not make sure that its outsourced vendor contracts included provisions for monitoring and oversight.
- The company had not conducted an Information Security (IS) Audit of its network and security systems since they were put in place.
- Although the company’s security system detected malware on a server and raised an alert, no action was taken. The company also did not store email security logs properly.
The most important point is that the security system worked and detected the problem. The failure was that the company did not act on the alert. RBI treated this as a governance failure, not a technology failure.
This case also shows that RBI can conduct a Control Gap Assessment at any time, separately from the annual inspection.
What should have been in place?
- Standard IT outsourcing agreements with audit rights and RBI access clauses.
- Annual Information Security Audits, with reports placed before the Audit Committee.
- A system to monitor security alerts, retain logs, and ensure timely action.
Case 4
RBI has increasingly focused on IT governance and cyber security compliance among NBFCs, imposing penalties for lapses in managing risks and code of conduct in outsourcing of financial services. In a recent RBI enforcement, the penalty followed a statutory inspection with reference to the company’s financial position at the time and focused on outsourcing conduct and fair lending practices.
The RBI found two issues:
- The company did not make sure that its recovery agents avoided harassment and intimidation of customers during debt collection.
- Customers made persistent and repeat complaints about harassment caused by the company’s recovery and collection methods.
The key point is that the complaints were not one-time incidents. They kept happening. RBI used the words “persistent/repeat”, which means the company either did not notice the problem or did not fix it, even though it continued. RBI treated this as a failure of management and oversight, not just an everyday operational issue.
This case also shows that outsourcing does not remove an NBFC’s responsibility. Even when recovery work is given to an outside agency, the NBFC remains responsible for how that agency’s recovery agents behave.
On 6 August 2026, RBI issued final directions on the recovery of loan dues and the engagement of recovery agents, which apply to NBFCs, banks and other lenders from 1 January 2027. Among other things, they require a written recovery policy, recovery agents certified by the Indian Institute of Banking and Finance, and call recording. What RBI penalised earlier is now being written into the rulebook.
What should the company have done?
- Make sure contracts with recovery agents clearly prohibit harassment and allow the company to audit the agency or end the contract if the rules are broken.
- Have a system to identify repeated complaints, escalate them, and report them to the compliance team or senior management.
- Check the behaviour of recovery agents regularly by reviewing call recordings, training records and customer complaints, instead of judging them only by how much they recover.
5. Where an Independent Compliance Audit Can Help Find These Gaps
The table below places the four cases side by side. For each case, it shows the violation, how RBI found it, and where an independent compliance audit could have found the gap before RBI did.
| Case | Core Violation | How RBI Found It | Where an Independent Compliance Audit Would Have Caught It |
| Case 1 | Wrong assessment of gold purity and weight, breaches of the loan-to-value (LTV) limit, cash disbursals above the legal limit, and a broken auction and refund process. | Regular RBI supervisory inspection (position at inspection date). RBI found serious concerns in the gold loan portfolio and, using its powers under Section 45L(1)(b) of the RBI Act, restricted new gold loans. | Sample testing of gold loan files for LTV and valuation; branch-wise reports of cash disbursals; matching of auction proceeds with refunds paid to borrowers; independent review of gold valuers. |
| Case 2 | PAN not verified through the official Income Tax portal; same customer given multiple UCICs | Routine RBI inspection of Know Your Customer (KYC) and anti-money laundering compliance | Sample check of new customer files for evidence of PAN verification; system report of customers holding more than one UCIC; test of the controls in the customer onboarding system. |
| Case 3 | Vendor contracts missing audit and oversight clauses, no Information Security (IS) audit since the systems went live, and a malware alert that was never acted on | RBI’s Control Gap Assessment, a targeted review that RBI can start at any time, separate from the annual inspection cycle | Review of vendor contracts for audit and oversight clauses; check that an IS audit has been done and placed before the Audit Committee; review of how security alerts are logged, assigned and closed. |
| Case 4 | Recovery agents harassing borrowers; complaints were persistent and repeated, not one time activity | Statutory RBI inspection reviewing outsourcing conduct and adherence to the Fair Practices Code | Review of recovery agent contracts; analysis of complaints by agent and branch; sample review of call recordings and training records; reporting of repeat complaints to senior management. |
Pattern across all four: In all four cases, the problem was not a one-time mistake. It was the lack of regular independent checks to ensure that the NBFC was following RBI requirements. RBI identified these issues during its inspections, which happen only from time to time. A regular independent compliance audit can help NBFCs identify and correct such gaps before RBI points them out. This is why NBFCs should not depend only on RBI inspections to identify compliance issues.
6. Conclusion
The four cases above carry one common message: regulatory issues rarely appear suddenly. They usually exist in the company’s own systems, records and processes long before RBI identifies them.
The role of a compliance audit is therefore not limited to checking whether documents exist. A meaningful audit tests whether controls actually work on the ground. It finds gaps before they become regulatory observations and helps the Board take corrective action in time.
RBI’s enforcement approach also shows that compliance is not only about avoiding penalties. A well-kept compliance framework, supported by proper documentation and timely corrective action, can strongly influence the outcome of regulatory proceedings. The fact that no action was taken on 316 of 698 charges in 2025-26, after the entities had replied, suggests how important it is to hold strong evidence of compliance.
For NBFCs, the message is clear: do not build compliance records after an RBI notice arrives. Build them every day as part of business operations.
The best defence against regulatory action is not a strong reply to an RBI notice. It is a strong compliance culture that makes sure the notice never arrives.
Bibliography
1. Reserve Bank of India, Annual Report 2022-23
2. Reserve Bank of India, Annual Report 2023-24
3. Reserve Bank of India, Annual Report 2024-25
4. Reserve Bank of India, Annual Report 2025-26
5. Reserve Bank of India, Press Releases
6. Reserve Bank of India, Non-Banking Financial Companies – Responsible Business Conduct Third Amendment Directions, 2026
Disclaimer: References are based on RBI’s public releases and reports and are included for knowledge-sharing purposes only. No opinion is expressed on the overall conduct of any of the Companies.
The article is written by Mr. Ashok Pathak.